CBR Reviews

New Avengers #58

Cover Price
$2.99 (USD)
Release Date
Oct 28th, 2009

Mon, November 2nd, 2009 at 7:56PM (PST)

Text Size

Since the launch of “Dark Avengers,” “New Avengers” has felt a little less vital than it used to. The edgy, streamlined stories that once graced its pages now belong to its sister series and, as a result, “New Avengers” has floundered, turning its mythology inwards –- particularly in setting up an ongoing rivalry with The Hood.

This issue, at least, blows out a few of the cobwebs, casting aside Bendis’ love of conversational scenes and slow, deliberate pacing in favor of a lot of Immonen-pencilled action. Throughout these scenes, Bendis delivers the kind of character moments that team books should be full of -- in particular, Ms. Marvel gets a classic moment against Norman Osborn that reminds us exactly why Osborn is doomed to failure and why Ms. Marvel was ever deemed worthy of being an Avengers leader.

Despite Bendis’ success with the details, it’s Immonen’s broad strokes that make the issue work. One could have never imagined that Ares fighting Bucky-Cap would ever look this jaw-dropping, and it’s a stark reminder of how good comic-drawn action can be under the right person’s pencils. Immonen’s style might not be photo-realistic or painted, but his skill lies in using so few lines to convey so much movement. Sequences like this remind you exactly where comics have the edge over other mediums.

This arc took a while to get going, but one good thing about “New Avengers” is that the stakes always feel high. The idea of this title having a status quo is laughable, so when Luke is taken away by Osborn, we actually feel as though he’s in danger. Similarly, when Jessica races off after him, there’s no guarantee she’ll come back. It’s easy to become cynical about the artificial peril comics characters find themselves in (“Will Spider-Man escape? Well ...yeah, it’s his series”) but “New Avengers” is one title precarious enough that some characters genuinely don’t seem bullet-proof.

If anything about “New Avengers” disappoints, it’s the sheer lack of focus on the Avengers themselves. At times, it feels as though Bendis is happy to write anyone but the team -– Night Nurse, The Hood, Osborn -- they all get a look in. That’s fine on occasion, but sometimes you wonder if the word “Avengers” belongs in the name at all...

SIMILAR REVIEWS

New Avengers #61
Posted Thu, January 28th

New Avengers #60
Posted Fri, December 25th

New Avengers #59
Posted Thu, November 26th

New Avengers #57
Posted Tue, September 22nd

New Avengers #58
Posted Thu, August 27th

Latest Columns

 Latest Columns Feed

Pipeline

Tue, February 9th | Augie De Blieck Jr.

This week, Augie reviews "Batman: The Cat and the Bat" and "Missile Mouse: The Star Crusher." Both are great fun, but only one has a character with a jet pack. Also, more thoughts on digital comic distribution to the iPad! [more...]

When Words Collide

Mon, February 8th | Timothy Callahan

Tim stops time to look closely at the Daredevil work of Brian Michael Bendis and Alex Maleev, this week through the lens of the four panel sequence that comprises the epic run's opening page. Comic book realism, exposed. [more...]

One Fan's Opinion

Fri, February 5th | Erik Larsen

This week, Erik looks at the ramifications of Apple's recently-announced iPad for the worlds of both print and digital comics, and tries to put the divide between the two media into perspective. [more...]